
Medicare fraud and scams targeting seniors have reached alarming levels in recent years. According to the National Health Care Anti-Fraud Association, healthcare fraud costs Americans tens of billions of dollars annually, with a significant portion targeting Medicare beneficiaries. Beyond the financial impact on the Medicare system itself, these scams can have devastating personal consequences for seniors, including identity theft, financial loss, and compromised medical care.
At American Assurance, we believe that education is the first line of defense against Medicare fraud. This guide will help you identify common Medicare scams, recognize warning signs, and take proactive steps to protect yourself and your loved ones.
Common Medicare Scams to Watch For
Scammers are constantly evolving their tactics, but most Medicare scams fall into several common categories. Being aware of these schemes is the first step toward avoiding them.
1. The "Free" Medical Equipment Scheme
How it works: Scammers contact Medicare beneficiaries offering “free” medical equipment such as back braces, knee braces, or diabetic supplies. They claim that Medicare will cover the cost completely, and all they need is your Medicare number to process the order.
The reality: Medicare only covers durable medical equipment that is medically necessary and prescribed by your doctor. These scammers bill Medicare for unnecessary or undelivered equipment, potentially exhausting your benefits when you genuinely need them.
Real-life example: In 2019, the Department of Justice charged 24 individuals involved in a $1.2 billion Medicare scam involving unnecessary orthotic braces. The scheme involved telemarketing calls, television and radio ads, and “health fairs” targeting Medicare beneficiaries.
2. The Medicare Card Replacement Scam
How it works: A caller claims to be from Medicare and says you need a new Medicare card. They might cite various reasons: your current card is expiring, it’s being upgraded, or there’s been a security breach requiring new cards. To send your new card, they need to verify your information, including your Medicare number, birth date, and sometimes even banking details.
The reality: Medicare will never call you to ask for your Medicare number—they already have it. The only time Medicare will contact you is if you’ve called them first and requested a callback.
Warning sign: Any unsolicited call requesting your Medicare number or personal information should immediately raise red flags.
3. Fraudulent Health Screenings
How it works: Scammers set up “free” health screenings at local events, shopping malls, or retirement communities. While they may perform basic tests like blood pressure checks, their primary goal is to collect your Medicare information.
The reality: These screenings are often used to bill Medicare for more complex tests that were never performed or to collect your personal information for identity theft.
What to know: Legitimate preventive screenings are an important Medicare benefit, but they should be coordinated through your healthcare provider, not random events or pop-up clinics.

4. The Enrollment Period Scheme
How it works: During Medicare’s Annual Enrollment Period (October 15-December 7), scammers pose as Medicare representatives or insurance agents claiming they need to “verify” your information to ensure you don’t lose coverage in the coming year.
The reality: These scammers take advantage of the legitimate enrollment period when many seniors are making real coverage decisions. They create a false sense of urgency to pressure you into providing personal information.
Protection tip: Remember that Medicare will not call you about enrollment unless you’ve requested information. Always initiate contact yourself through official Medicare channels.
5. Medication Discount Card Scams
How it works: Scammers offer fake prescription drug discount cards, claiming they’ll provide substantial savings on your medications. To receive the card, you must provide personal information, including your Medicare number.
The reality: These fake discount programs either charge enrollment fees for non-existent benefits or use your information for identity theft and fraudulent billing.
What to know: Legitimate prescription discount programs do exist, but they should never require your Medicare number, and they’re not affiliated with Medicare.

Red Flags That Signal a Medicare Scam
Regardless of the specific scheme, most Medicare scams share common warning signs. Be immediately suspicious if you encounter any of these red flags:
Unsolicited Contact
Medicare will almost never contact you without your prior request. Be wary of any unsolicited:
Requests for Personal Information
Be extremely cautious if anyone asks for:
Scammers often create a false sense of urgency to pressure you into making quick decisions without proper consideration. Watch out for phrases like:
“Free” Offers That Seem Too Good to Be True
Be skeptical of offers for:
Claims of Medicare Endorsement
Medicare doesn’t endorse specific companies, products, or services. Be suspicious of any company claiming to be “Medicare-approved” or “working with Medicare” on a special program.

How Scammers Get Your Information
Understanding how scammers obtain your information can help you take steps to protect yourself more effectively.
Large-scale data breaches at healthcare providers, insurance companies, and other organizations can expose your personal information. While you can’t prevent these breaches, you can monitor your Medicare statements carefully for signs of fraud.
Scammers collect information from public records, obituaries, social media, and other sources to target potential victims. They may know details about you that make their scams seem more legitimate.
Emails, texts, or phone calls designed to trick you into revealing personal information are common in Medicare scams. These communications often mimic official Medicare correspondence.
Scammers use psychological manipulation to gain trust and extract information. They may pose as authority figures, create false emergencies, or exploit natural human tendencies to be helpful.
Steps to Protect Yourself from Medicare Scams
Taking these proactive measures can significantly reduce your risk of becoming a victim of Medicare fraud.
Your Medicare number should be treated with the same care as your Social Security number or credit card information:
Check Your Medicare Statements Regularly
Medicare sends a Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) every three months or an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) from your Medicare Advantage plan. Review these documents carefully:
Use Official Channels for Medicare Communication
Always initiate contact through official Medicare channels:
Be Cautious with Healthcare Decisions
Use the Medicare Fraud Reporting System
If you suspect Medicare fraud:
What to Do If You've Been Scammed
If you suspect you’ve fallen victim to a Medicare scam, taking immediate action can help limit the damage.
After a Medicare scam, be vigilant for signs of broader identity theft:
Keep detailed records of the scam and your response:
Special Considerations During Medicare Enrollment Periods
The Annual Enrollment Period (October 15-December 7) and Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1-March 31) are prime times for Medicare scams. During these periods:
Helping Vulnerable Family Members
Older adults with cognitive impairments or those who are less familiar with common scam tactics may be especially vulnerable to Medicare fraud. If you’re caring for a loved one:
How American Assurance Helps Protect Clients
At American Assurance, we’re committed to helping our clients navigate Medicare safely and effectively. Our approach includes:
We understand that Medicare can be complex, and our goal is to be a trusted resource you can turn to for honest guidance and support.

Conclusion: Staying Vigilant Against Medicare Fraud
Medicare scams are unfortunately common, but knowledge and vigilance are powerful tools for protection. By understanding the warning signs, taking preventive measures, and knowing how to respond if targeted, you can significantly reduce your risk of becoming a victim.
Remember these key points:
If you have questions about Medicare or suspect you may have encountered a scam, contact American Assurance today. Our team of experienced advisors is ready to help you navigate Medicare with confidence and security.
This information is current as of 2023 but may change as new scams emerge. American Assurance specializes in helping seniors navigate their insurance options with integrity and transparency. We are committed to protecting our clients from fraud while helping them secure the coverage they truly need.
ReplyForward Add reaction |