
Social Security represents one of the most important retirement resources for most Americans, providing a foundation of inflation-protected, guaranteed lifetime income. However, many people claim these valuable benefits without understanding the long-term implications of their claims decisions.
The difference between an optimal claiming strategy and a suboptimal one can amount to tens—or even hundreds—of thousands of dollars in lifetime benefits. At American Assurance, we believe that informed Social Security decisions are crucial to a secure retirement. This guide will help you understand the strategies that could maximize your lifetime benefits.
Understanding the Basics: How Social Security Works
Before diving into specific maximization strategies, it’s important to understand some fundamental concepts about Social Security benefits:
To qualify for retirement benefits based on your own work record, you generally need 40 “credits” (roughly 10 years of work) paying into the Social Security system. Spouses can qualify for benefits based on their current spouse’s record (spousal benefits) or deceased spouse’s record (survivor benefits), even if they have limited or no work history of their own.
Your Full Retirement Age is when you’re eligible to receive 100% of your earned benefit. For people born between 1943 and 1954, FRA is 66. For those born after 1954, FRA gradually increases until it reaches 67 for people born in 1960 or later.
Cost of Living Adjustments (COLAs)
Social Security benefits include annual cost of living adjustments to help protect against inflation. These adjustments apply to your benefit amount regardless of when you claim, but larger initial benefits mean larger dollar increases over time.

Key Factors That Influence Your Optimal Claiming Strategy
Your optimal Social Security claiming strategy depends on several personal factors:
Maximization Strategies for Different Situations

Now let’s explore specific claiming strategies for different situations:
For never-married, divorced (without claiming on an ex-spouse’s record), or widowed individuals who will only claim on their own record:
Strategy 1: Delay to Maximize Monthly Benefits
If you can afford to do so, delaying benefits until age 70 provides the largest possible monthly benefit—up to 76% more than claiming at 62. This strategy is particularly valuable for those who:
Example: Maria has a full retirement age of 66 and 4 months, with a benefit of $2,000 at FRA. By delaying until 70, her benefit grows to approximately $2,613 per month. If she lives to 90, this decision results in over $100,000 in additional lifetime benefits compared to claiming at FRA, even after accounting for the years of missed benefits.
Strategy 2: Break-Even Analysis
For those unsure about delaying, consider the “break-even age”—the age at which the cumulative benefits from delaying surpass the cumulative benefits from claiming earlier.
If you expect to live beyond these ages, delaying generally results in greater lifetime benefits.
Married couples have more complex decisions because they need to coordinate two benefit histories and consider survivor benefits.
Strategy 1: Higher-Earner Delays, Lower-Earner Claims Earlier
In many cases, the optimal strategy for married couples involves:
This strategy works because:
Example: John and Sarah are both 62. John’s FRA benefit is $2,800, while Sarah’s is $1,200. Sarah claims at 62, receiving $900 monthly (reduced for early claiming). John delays until 70, increasing his benefit to $3,680. This maximizes their household income during their joint lifetime and ensures that whichever spouse survives will receive John’s higher benefit for the remainder of their life.
Strategy 2: File at Full Retirement Age for Lower-Earning Spouse
In some cases, having the lower-earning spouse wait until their FRA to claim spousal benefits (50% of the higher earner’s FRA benefit) can be advantageous, especially if:
Note: Since the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015, restricted applications for spousal benefits only are limited to those born before January 2, 1954.
Strategy 3: Coordinate Around Other Income Sources
Couples with significant retirement assets or pension income can create a comprehensive income plan that considers:
If you were married for at least 10 years and haven’t remarried, you may be eligible for benefits based on your ex-spouse’s record.
Strategy: Claim on Ex-Spouse’s Record
Example: Linda was married to Robert for 12 years before divorcing. Linda’s benefit at FRA is $800, while 50% of Robert’s FRA benefit is $1,400. Linda can claim the higher spousal benefit based on Robert’s record, even if he hasn’t yet claimed his own benefits.
Surviving spouses have special claiming options that can significantly increase lifetime benefits.
Strategy 1: Claim Survivor Benefits First, Then Switch
If you’re widowed, you can:
This strategy allows you to receive some benefits earlier while still maximizing your own benefit through delayed retirement credits.
Example: Michael is widowed at 60. His deceased wife had a benefit of $1,800. Michael’s own benefit at FRA (66) would be $2,400, or $3,168 if delayed to age 70. Michael could claim reduced survivor benefits of approximately $1,296 at age 60, then switch to his own benefit at age 70, maximizing his lifetime benefits.
Strategy 2: Claim Retirement Benefits First, Then Survivor Benefits
Alternatively, you can:
This strategy can be beneficial if your own benefit is relatively small compared to the survivor benefit.
Special Considerations for Maximization
Working While Receiving Benefits
If you claim benefits before your FRA and continue working:
For many individuals who continue working, delaying benefits until at least FRA makes financial sense to avoid these reductions.
While Social Security and Medicare are separate programs, they’re often coordinated:
Delaying Social Security doesn’t affect your Medicare enrollment timeline.
Strategic claiming can help manage the taxation of your benefits:
Common Myths and Misconceptions

Myth 1: “I should claim as soon as possible because Social Security is going bankrupt.”
Reality: While the Social Security trust fund is projected to face challenges, even in the worst-case scenario, the system would still pay approximately 76% of promised benefits from ongoing payroll taxes. Major changes to the program would almost certainly include protections for those at or near retirement age.
Myth 2: “It’s always best to claim early at 62.”
Reality: Claiming at 62 results in a permanent reduction of 25-30% compared to your FRA benefit. For many people, especially those with average or better life expectancy, delaying benefits results in significantly greater lifetime benefits.
Myth 3: “I should claim at 62 because I can invest the money better myself.”
Reality: To beat the guaranteed 8% per year increase for delaying Social Security (plus inflation adjustments), you would need to achieve consistent above-average returns while taking on considerable investment risk. Few investment strategies can guarantee the risk-adjusted returns offered by delaying Social Security.
Myth 4: “If I die early after delaying, I lose money.”
Reality: For married couples, even if the spouse who delayed benefits dies relatively early, the surviving spouse will receive the higher benefit for the remainder of their life. This survivor benefit protection makes delaying the higher earner’s benefit valuable even if that individual doesn’t live to the break-even age.

Case Studies: Social Security Maximization in Action
Case Study 1: Single Individual with Longevity
Barbara, age 62, has a full retirement age of 67, with a projected benefit of $2,600 at FRA. She’s in excellent health, with several family members who lived into their 90s. Barbara has adequate savings and can support herself without claiming Social Security immediately.
Strategy: Barbara decides to delay claiming until age 70, increasing her monthly benefit to $3,224. If Barbara lives to age 90, this decision will provide approximately $95,000 more in lifetime benefits compared to claiming at 62, even after accounting for the 8 years of missed benefits.
Case Study 2: Married Couple with Age Difference
James (62) and Patricia (59) have been married for 30 years. James’s FRA benefit is $2,800, while Patricia’s is $1,300. James has some health concerns but Patricia comes from a long-lived family.
Strategy: James claims at his FRA (66 and 6 months), receiving $2,800 monthly. When Patricia reaches 62, she claims her own reduced benefit of $975. Upon James’s death (regardless of when it occurs), Patricia will step up to his full benefit amount as a survivor benefit. This approach balances providing current income while protecting Patricia with a higher survivor benefit for what could be many years as a widow.
Case Study 3: Divorced Individual with Options
Thomas (63) was married to Elizabeth for 15 years before divorcing 10 years ago. He hasn’t remarried. Thomas’s FRA benefit is $1,800, while 50% of Elizabeth’s FRA benefit would be $1,500.
Strategy: Thomas decides to claim his own benefit at age 67 (his FRA), receiving $1,800 monthly. Since his own benefit exceeds what he would receive as an ex-spousal benefit, he claims solely on his own record. However, knowing he had the ex-spousal benefit option provided peace of mind during his planning process.
Taking Action: Steps to Maximize Your Benefits
1. Create Your my Social Security Account
Visit ssa.gov to create your personal account, which allows you to:
2. Understand Your Full Retirement Age
Knowing your FRA is essential for understanding the impact of claiming earlier or later:
3. Estimate Your Life Expectancy
While no one can predict their exact lifespan, consider:
The Social Security Administration offers a life expectancy calculator at ssa.gov/planners/
4. Calculate Your Break-Even Ages
Determine the ages at which delaying benefits would result in greater lifetime benefits compared to claiming earlier. This calculation helps you evaluate the trade-offs based on your life expectancy.
5. Consider Your Overall Retirement Income Plan
Social Security should be considered within the context of your complete retirement income strategy, including:
6. Consult with a Financial Professional
Given the complexity and significance of Social Security claiming decisions, working with a knowledgeable financial professional can provide valuable insights tailored to your specific situation.
Conclusion: Making an Informed Decision
Social Security claiming is one of the most important financial decisions you’ll make for retirement. The right strategy depends on your unique circumstances, including your health, marital status, financial needs, and overall retirement plan.
By understanding the factors that influence optimal claiming and exploring the strategies that align with your situation, you can make informed decisions that potentially increase your lifetime benefits by tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars.
At American Assurance, our experienced financial professionals specialize in helping clients navigate these complex decisions as part of a comprehensive retirement income strategy. We consider all aspects of your financial situation to develop personalized recommendations that align with your goals and circumstances.
Ready to explore how to maximize your Social Security benefits as part of your retirement plan? Contact American Assurance today for a complimentary Social Security maximization analysis with one of our experienced financial professionals.
American Assurance brings together industry veterans with over two decades of experience and partners with carriers that have been protecting families for more than a century. We’re dedicated to providing comprehensive financial planning and protection services to families nationwide. We specialize in working with individuals at all life stages, offering customized programs that meet your specific needs and budget while delivering the stability and security that comes from our established industry partnerships.